If you love grilling barbecue every weekend, you should be getting the right equipment. From the barbecue grill to the covers and smoker tools, there are many things to consider.
Yet there’s one thing that people often take for granted: grill mats. Sure, they seem weird at first, but they will ease the whole cooking process. Essentially, grill mats are thin layers of non-stick, heat-resistant material that provide cooks with a clean surface.
Whether you want to prevent moisture loss or to simply catch drips, these rectangular mats will do just the trick. They do look similar to each other, but not all grill mats provide the same quality performance. This is why we’ve conducted our own research to identify the best grill mat.
Zoom Out: Top 5 Grill Mats That You Can Buy In 2019
It’s easy to just randomly choose a pack of grill mats, but that doesn’t guarantee they’ll live up to expectations. Some of them are simply too flimsy to grill on, while others are too thick. Below, you’ll see five products we deemed worthy of being picked as the best grill mat.
|Grill Mat||Item Weight||Color|
|ISUDA Nonstick Grill Mat||15.8 ounces||Black|
|My Cozy Home Grilling Mat||9.6 ounces||Black|
|Kitchen Joy Grill Mat (Editor's Pick!)||8 ounces||Black|
|SUMGOTT Grill Mat||3.2 ounces||Black|
|The Original Grill Pad Brown Grill Pad||8 pounds||Brown|
As you can see, their product names only really vary by brand name. Furthermore, only one of them features a non-black color, which is also significantly heavier than the rest. To understand why we selected these as the best grill mats, check out our individual reviews.
ISUDA Nonstick Grill Mat – Heat-Resistant Mats for Flavorful Food
First, we have the nonstick grill mat from ISUDA. With a size of 16” by 13”, the ISUDA nonstick grill mat primarily aims to provide a decent surface to any type of outdoor grill, especially while camping out in the woods.
Of course, this product is also advertised for home use – something that regular barbecue grillers should take into consideration. Whether you use a Charbroil grill, a propane grill, or a standard smoker grill, the ISUDA nonstick grill mat should work just fine. These are designed to prevent any type of food from going down the grates or annoyingly getting stuck to the grill.
Specifically, they are made of fiberglass fabric coated PTFE or Teflon. This is the same material used to create non-stick pans. Thus, flipping food – even without using cooking oil – should be quick and easy.
Instead of going for thickness, ISUDA capitalized on sleekness. The company rigorously observed the output of grill mats in varying thicknesses, and they’ve apparently managed to find the right thinness. In other words, the ISUDA nonstick grill mats are built to prevent grill marks and retain the flavor while still being durable and heat-resistant.
In particular, these can resist heat as high as 500 degrees Fahrenheit. Food will taste better and cleaning duties after BBQ grill parties shouldn’t be much of a hassle with grill mats. Aside from these properties, these ISUDA grill mats can also be reused and cleaned using a dishwasher.
All the juices and oils don’t go away since the mat keeps them from falling down the slits of the grill. Essentially, we got the best flavors while also keeping the cleanliness of the grill in check. Whenever we cooked small vegetables like peppers, we no longer had to worry about the smallest pieces accidentally falling into the grill.
Once the grilling and eating are done, we just had to use soap and water to clean and prepare the mat for its next use. Still, there is a noticeable difference that is dependent on the type of food being cooked.
For example, it’s really quick to clean the ISUDA grill mat if only vegetables were grilled there. However, if one were to grill meat with high-fat content, cleaning them might take more than a few scrubs. Of course, lean meat like chicken breasts does not lead to the same prolonged cleaning process.
Are grill mats safe? Well, they definitely prevent deadly flare-ups.
What We Liked
- ?Surprisingly durable
- ?Heat resistant for up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit
- ?Very easy to clean
- Food is more tender and flavorful
What We Didn’t Like
- Requires thorough cleaning after grilling high-fat food
My Cozy Home Grilling Mat – Durable Mat with a Lifetime Warranty
The My Cozy Home Grilling Mat was developed to sustain the flavors of grilled food. With its nonstick characteristic, how exactly does this mat differentiate itself from the other BBQ grill mats?
These grill mats are made to be as portable as possible. Whether we were on our way to a picnic or we just wanted to grill our favorite steak at another neighbor’s barbecue grill, these lightweight grill mats were always around.
Furthermore, the non-stick property assures that we only had to slide the meat off from the mat once adequately grilled. This also means you don’t necessarily have to apply any sort of oil or fat to get the best-tasting grilled food. Ideally, this saves you from accumulating all those extra calories.
Since the My Cozy Home Grilling Mat is made of polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) fiberglass, we are assured that it’s relatively durable and safe to use. This grill mat resists heat as high as 500 degrees Fahrenheit.
Accordingly, these grill mats should last a user many years if adequate care is practiced. Speaking of maintenance, you only need soap, water, and a sponge to get this BBQ grill mat ready for another use. If you want, you have the option to clean it with a dishwasher instead.
For any issues, the company provides a commendable lifetime warranty. You don’t even have to return the My Cozy Home Grilling Mat. Simply contact the company about the problem, and they’ll provide you not just a refund but also a replacement product.
The My Cozy Home Grilling Mat works well with a variety of food. If you like seafood and grilling fish, in particular, you will appreciate this product. Vegetables such as bell peppers and zucchini tasted absolutely wonderful while freshly grilled fish was just as delectable.
Moving on, we noticed that a single grill mat is enough to cover two burners. If you want to cover the entire burner grill, just add the appropriate amount of grill mats.
In conclusion, the My Cozy Home Grilling Mat does its job well. Food no longer falls down the grill, the flavors are rich, and we get to reduce the cleaning time and the oil used. In addition, the lifetime warranty is an incredible offer that is hard to refuse.
Enjoy using this grill mat outdoor without worrying the mosquitoes around you. Check out our guide about the best mosquito trap right here!
What We Liked
- ?Made of durable and safe PTFE fiberglass
- ?Vegetables and fish taste incredible
- ?Lifetime warranty is hard to pass
- Reduces cleaning time and oil usage
What We Didn’t Like
- Scrubbing the grill mat not always quick to do
Kitchen Joy Grill Mat – Anti-Slip Mat with an Ultra-Thick Core
Our third BBQ grill mat review is for a product from Kitchen Joy, and these grill mats truly looked like they could deliver the best-grilled food. Instead of thinness, however, the Kitchen Joy Grill Mat relies on a bit of thickness.
Embracing thickness as a selling point, the Kitchen Joy Grill Mat boasts of an “ultra-thick” core meant to withstand heat as high as 500 degrees Fahrenheit. They are completely free of perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) and have the standard PTFE fiberglass coating.
As long the heat is manageable, this grill mat wouldn’t go up in flames or even show signs of shrinking. Essentially, this is a heavy-duty type of grill mat. It’s common for brands to state how heat-resistant their grill mats are, but it’s quite something else when they don’t even burn and shrink.
Kitchen Joy also mentioned that the company utilized a special kind of technology to stop flare-ups, and we were obviously eager to test that out.
Ideally, this should result in vegetables and meat getting just enough heat while also getting the visually appealing grill marks. Of course, these Kitchen Joy grill mats are smooth and feature completely non-stick surfaces – eliminating the need to use oils and fats.
In addition, this allows individuals to bring not only barbecue but also eggs and even pizzas to the grill.
The company indicates their grill mats can last for years, given that people would take care of them properly. Thankfully, it’s quite easy to clean grill mats.
The Kitchen Joy Grill Mat can be cleaned with a dishwasher, so you won’t always have to manually and painstakingly scrub the grease and fat off.
Moreover, Kitchen Joy is generous enough to offer you a complete refund if you found the grill mats underwhelming. Specifically, you have ten years to use this option if the grill mats were far from satisfactory.
The Kitchen Joy Grill Mat worked well most of the time. Some of us were worried that a relatively thick grill mat would not provide enough heat, but the chicken meat we served was quite delectable and filled with flavor.
This is because the marinade we prepared didn’t just go down to the grill bars. Instead, they remained on the chicken to give it enough taste. If the Kitchen Joy Grill Mat wasn’t used, the meat wouldn’t have been as scrumptious.
As for vegetables like stuffed peppers, there is nothing you have to worry about. They are grilled with utmost perfection. As for grilling fish like swordfish and salmon, you’d be glad to know that flipping them is easy. The resulting food always features grill marks without any of the excessively burnt areas.
Even after constant use, the smooth and reliable quality of the Kitchen Joy Grill Mat hasn’t waned at all.
What We Liked
- ?Ultra-thick core offers great durability and heat resistance
- ?10-year money back guarantee
- ?PFOA-free PTFE fiberglass coating
- Readily prevents flare-ups and slips
What We Didn’t Like
- Grill marks not always as deep as others want
SUMGOTT Grill Mat – Easy to Clean and Highly Reusable
Up next in our reviews is the SUMGOTT Grill Mat – might not be a familiar to many people, but the quality of this product might just change that soon enough.
Whether you’re preparing asparagus or portions of chicken breast, the SUMGOTT Grill Mat promises to prevent any bits of food from falling through the grill grates.
It also serves to make grilling easier by being more practical to use than a grill pan or basket. Likewise, this SUMGOTT product should eliminate the need for aluminum foil. Just like the other grill mats in this review, the SUMGOTT variant should work in any type of barbecue grill, including Weber and Char-Broil grills.
These grill mats are 16” x 13” in size and are also made of PTFE fiberglass coating. The non-stick flat surface of this barbecue grill mat assures that the food you prepare gets evenly grilled while getting the sought-after grill marks.
Whether you’re cooking chicken wings, juicy burgers, or vegetables, the SUMGOTT Grill Mat should work well up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit.
As for cleaning, these are also dishwasher safe. Aside from keeping your grill clean, cleaning this for future use shouldn’t be stressful.
These grill mats, however, are made thick. In fact, this is 0.39-millimeter thick mat that can be used more than a thousand times per side. In other words, it significantly has more uses – as much as 50 times more –than the average grilling mat.
To our delight and utter surprise, the SUMGOTT grill mats really do prevent even the meatiest and juiciest food to get stuck. From cooking meatballs to the good old sausages, they were bursting in flavor thanks to these mats. If there was one minor issue we identified, it’s that grilling red meat could lead to a grease fire.
As much as we want to stop using oils and fats, we do have to admit that greasy red meat is still hard to deny. Thus, you have to be extra careful when you’re grilling red meat – or any other incredibly greasy food, for that matter.
What We Liked
- PTFE fiberglass coating
- ?Immensely reusable thanks to the mat thickness
- ?Cleaning is simple and easy
- Lays down flat upon exposure to heat
What We Didn’t Like
- Need to be extra careful when grilling red meat
The Original Grill Pad Brown Grill Pad – Immensely Tough and Sizable Mat
Finally, we have the only grill mat on our list that isn’t colored black. Featuring a brown appearance, what makes it so special to be among the best grill mats for 2019? Read on.
Developed by none other than Diversitech and crafted by hand in the United States, this brown grill pad is designed to be compatible with nearly every gas and charcoal grill in the market.
What makes the Original Grill Pad unique, aside from its color, is that it is made not only for charcoal and gas grills but also for composite decking. In order to make this a possibility, Diversitech created a special material made up of fiber cement.
In turn, this material gives the Original Grill Pad its ability to effectively resist heat and weather. The exclusive material also stops the brown grill mat from degradation, melting, and corrosion — issues that constantly affect grills made of plastic or metal. At eight pounds in weight, this product easily stays on the ground.
We learned that the Original Grill Pad lacks a rubber backing component, essentially assuring us it will be a non-stick grill mat like the others.
As for cleaning, Diversitech made sure that all the spills and the nasty grease simply converge at the top for easy removal and wiping. In fact, the brand says no scrubbing is needed as long as soap and wiping are applied. Of course, users are expected to provide sufficient maintenance, which shouldn’t be difficult as there’s an included instruction manual.
The Original Grill Pad definitely proved its reputation as a tough grill mat. This brown mat easily held the grill in place. Yes, it feels brittle, but this product is very sturdy.
Moving this product is not as easy to do compared to the four mats we reviewed, but its weight and size make it the ideal grill mat for a wooded deck.
All in all, this the heavy-duty grill mat that many owners are looking for. They are superbly resistant to damage by the elements.
Grilling is fun when it is done in your lawn, to make it more fun add an inflatable pool near to it. Read our guide about the best inflatable pool here!
What We Liked
- ?Amazing heat resistance and weather resistance
- ?Special fiber cement material assures durability
- ?No scrubbing needed to clean
- Good for grills and composite decking
What We Didn’t Like
- Relatively heavy
In the end, we think that one of these grill mats deserves the highest recognition. With an ultra-thick core for sturdiness and heat resistance, the Kitchen Joy Grill Mat is our top choice for buying a grill mat. It superbly prevents slips and flare-ups while having a PFOA-free PTFE fiberglass coating.
Whether you’re grilling fish, vegetables, or pork, the food will taste great. Furthermore, you cannot deny the value of a 10-year money back guarantee. Due to the impressive performance time and again, the Kitchen Joy Grill Mat is our best grill mat.
Now that you’ve read the best grill mat, take time to read our guide about the best zero turn mower for hills. This might help to decide what to buy.
Did you like what you read? If so, please rate this guide
Dean is a freelance copy-editor from Utah, where he lives with his wife and two daughters. His garden is a place to relax after a stressful day of work, have a beer and play in the pool with his girls.